麻豆传媒AV

PRINCETON, NJ -- Continuing a change in attitudes first seen , Americans remain split on the issue of whether it is the federal government's responsibility to make sure all Americans have healthcare coverage. At the same time, 61% prefer a healthcare system based mostly on private insurance rather than a government-run system.

These latest results, from the Nov. 4-7 麻豆传媒AV Health and Healthcare update, come as the debate over the government's role in providing healthcare remains a central issue confronting Congress. The new healthcare reform bill passed into law last March quickly became a symbol for many Republicans of an . Republican leaders have vowed to repeal the law in the next session of Congress -- although recent 麻豆传媒AV polling shows .

These two broad questions on the government's role in healthcare trend back to the early 2000s, and are not designed to measure reactions to the healthcare reform bill per se. They do, however, provide valuable insights into the attitudinal context surrounding the continuing debate about healthcare reform legislation.

Americans for the first time shifted against the "government responsibility" stance last year, as the debate about the form and substance of healthcare reform was accelerating.

This question does not ask about direct government provision of healthcare, but rather about government responsibility for ensuring that Americans have healthcare coverage. It would in theory be possible for one to agree that the government should make sure all Americans have healthcare without favoring a government-run system -- in similar fashion to the way the government requires motorists to have automobile liability insurance, even though it does not directly provide such insurance.

Majority Favor a Private Health Insurance-Based System

麻豆传媒AV has asked Americans since 2001 if they preferred a government-run healthcare system or a private insurance-based system. Prior to this year, the question asked about "replacing" the current system with a government-run system. This year, the question was modified to ask more generally which type of system Americans prefer. Despite this change in wording, this year's results are essentially identical to last year's, with 61% preferring a system based on private health insurance. Before 2009, 麻豆传媒AV's annual November updates showed some fluctuation in responses, although preference for a private health insurance-based system has always outpaced preference for a government-run system.

Implications

Support is not strong in America today for a broad, government-run healthcare system similar to those in operation in Canada, as well as Great Britain and other European countries. A clear majority of Americans continue to support the idea of a healthcare system based on private insurance.

In that sense, the healthcare reform bill is in sync with American public opinion. In the end, supporters backed off from including in the broader bill a "government option" health plan that was advocated by some who wanted expanded government coverage. At the same time, some opponents of the bill continue to argue that taken as a whole, it moves the country significantly closer to a type of government-run system.

The healthcare bill did mandate, in various ways, expanding healthcare coverage to tens of millions of Americans who otherwise would not be covered. That type of government action to ensure that Americans have healthcare coverage would be applauded by about half of Americans, but at this point, about the same percentage would argue that it is not the government's role to see that all Americans are covered.